HomeEditorial policy

Editorial Policy

How we test data rooms, how we score them, and how this site makes money — written so you can hold us to it.

How we make money

Some links to data room providers on this site may carry referral terms, which means we may earn a commission when you sign up after clicking them. No provider pays for placement, and no provider can pay to change a score, a ranking position, or a verdict. Who we are and how to reach us is on the About page.

Papermark is our recommended pick for startups and lean deal teams. It earns the top spot in value-weighted rankings because pricing transparency and total cost are heavily weighted criteria in our rubric — a choice we defend openly, since we believe hidden pricing is the category's biggest buyer problem. Where other providers are better, we say so: our own pages recommend Datasite, Intralinks, and iDeals for large enterprise M&A and credit Ansarada for publishing its rates.

The scoring rubric

Every ranked list on this site uses the same weighted criteria. The weights are the editorial position; the scores under them are reproducible from the cited evidence.

CriterionWeightWhat we measure
Pricing transparency & total cost30%Published rate cards score higher than quote-only models. Total cost is modeled for a typical lean deal team (3 admins, ~50 reviewers, 2–5 GB, 6 months).
Core security controls25%Granular permissions, dynamic watermarking, NDA gating, audit trails, and access revocation — verified in the plan tier we quote, not the top tier.
Ease of setup & reviewer experience20%Time from signup to a working room, guest-side friction, and how fast a non-admin can find documents.
Deal workflow depth15%Q&A workflows, staged access, analytics, and reporting for live diligence processes.
Support & reliability10%Support channels and responsiveness, uptime posture, and certifications (SOC 2, ISO 27001).

Testing and sourcing rules

  • Hands-on first. Where a trial exists, we build a real room, invite guests, and test the controls we list. Features we could not verify are attributed to vendor documentation.
  • Prices are cited or labeled. Published prices link to official pages. Quote-only vendors get reported ranges from multiple independent sources, always labeled as estimates.
  • Every review names weaknesses. Including Papermark's: it does not offer managed Q&A at enterprise scale, and our pages route those deals to competitors.
  • Third-party comparisons get real verdicts. An "iDeals vs Intralinks" page declares a winner between those two on the merits; Papermark appears only as a clearly marked sidebar where genuinely relevant.
  • Honest dates. "Last updated" changes only when the content materially changes.
  • Link policy. We do not sell followed links; outbound links to providers generally carry rel="nofollow".

Corrections

We correct factual errors quickly and update the affected page's date. Report issues on the site's GitHub repository.